Why hasn’t this happened already? Portal and Portal 2 are masterpieces, with the 2011 sequel successfully expanding on the first game’s amazing puzzle game base with an intriguing story, improved script, and more diverse environments. A third game would surely be even better. It wouldn’t even have to do much! It’s been long enough that just more Portal would likely be satisfactory for a lot of people.
But this is Valve we’re talking about. As we all know, this company doesn’t just make games for the sake of it. The developer even seems happy to almost troll its own fans by allowing other companies to use the Portal license in their own games: the past few years have seen Rocket League and Lego Dimensions recieve Portal-related content, and last year we even got a full game crossover with Bridge Constructor. And yet, still no proper sequel.
We might be waiting a long time for Portal 3. If only those wormholes allowed us to travel through time… | Oscar Dayus
Silent Hills | PS4, Xbox One, PC
Despite game director Hideo Kojima’s very public departure from Konami, the company is still seems adamant about supporting the auteur’s Metal Gear series. Kojima was also tied to the next game in Konami’s Silent Hill franchise, and while that project (a collaboration with film director Guillermo del Toro and actor Norman Reedus) is canceled, Konami has publicly stated that the Silent Hill franchise will continue on at some point. And despite Konami’s issues, Silent Hill is still a tortured video game location that we’d want to visit again.
Spanning multiple developers and a wide range of protagonists, the series is uniquely positioned for a follow-up that doesn’t strictly adhere to the games of the past. And a success with the long-running horror franchise could potentially mitigate the disastrous PR left by Kojima’s departure. It seems like a sure thing that Konami will get around to making another entry in the franchise, and even though it would’ve been fascinating to see what a horror mashup between Kojmia and del Toro would have been like, we’ll likely get a taste of that in Death Stranding. The next Silent Hill will be a new creature, but what form it takes has yet to be decided. Hopefully, it can return to its critically acclaimed roots, and avoid being another average spin-off like Downpour and Book of Memories. | Justin Haywald
Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic 3 | PS4, Xbox One, PC
Though there have been many games that have taken advantage of the Star Wars brand to great effect, one title in particular has stood out for many fans of the storied franchise. Bioware’s narrative-focused RPG Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic followed the adventures of an up-and-coming Jedi and their crew as they explored the galaxy, thousands of years before the rise of the Empire. At its time, it was a rather seminal game for the Star Wars series. Instead of shoehorning new characters into established lore and repeating moments from the films, this RPG title told its own story with a memorable cast of characters. While KOTOR had two sequels, one of which was the moderately successful MMO The Old Republic, there’s been a yearning for a third game focusing on the single player experience with modern visuals and systems.
However, much has changed with the Star Wars IP in recent years, and making a direct sequel isn’t so clear cut. With Disney having acquired the Star Wars license, while also jettisoning much of the material from the 40-years of expanded universe fiction–including the plot of KOTOR–a follow-up would have to be a reboot. While this may draw the ire of hardcore fans, this also presents a wonderful opportunity to tell fresh stories with new characters.
A Star Wars RPG seems well overdue, and with Bioware a part of EA–and with the publisher currently possessing the exclusive rights to produce Star Wars games–the timing seems perfect for the original developers to return to the Star Wars universe. Which should totally happen sooner, rather than later. | Alessandro Fillari
Super Mario Maker 2 | Switch
Mario Maker was one of the last hurrahs for Wii U owners, and what an event it was. It offered a chance for people to get creative with one of gaming’s greatest icons, share Mario levels they’ve created online, and browse through thousands of levels made by other passionate players across the globe. If you followed game culture in 2015 and 2016, you probably saw plenty of people sharing videos of tremendously difficult stages being bested by skilled (or lucky) players; a testament to the game’s widespread popularity and its effectiveness as a game creation tool.
The Wii U GamePad touchscreen made the process of creating and editing levels a breeze, and all it takes is one look at your Switch to realize that it’s built for a game like Mario Maker. Given that Switch’s online environment is still a work in progress, it’s understandable why Nintendo isn’t rushing to make it happen, but given the massive Switch install base (relative to Wii U), it’s easy to imagine that we’ll see the next Maker game sometime down the road. | Peter Brown
Super Mario RPG 2 | Switch
Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars blessed the SNES back in 1996, where our franchise favorite characters banded together to fight common enemies throughout the Mushroom Kingdom… in the form of a turn-based RPG. Squaresoft had created Final Fantasy VI, Chrono Trigger, and Secret of Mana by this time, but to wrap its refined RPG elements in the Mario universe made for one of the best mash-up/collaborations ever. Bowser was driven out of his castle, Peach was fed up with being held captive, and newcomers Geno and Mallow joined Mario in an adventure through new places that gave a nod to what we’ve seen in previous Mario games. What tied everything together and ingrained this game into our memories was the catchy, joyful soundtrack full of songs with layered instrumentation. You’ve probably heard the infectious “Beware the Forest Mushrooms” before. And shout out to those that fought Culex to the rearrangement of Final Fantasy IV’s boss battle theme.
Paper Mario, and its follow-up The Thousand Year Door, are incredible games in their own right, but are essentially spiritual successors separate from the world that was built in Legend of the Seven Stars. In this day and age however, the appetite for Mario spin-offs is strong; we got a tactical strategy game with Rabbids, and a remake of Superstar Saga on 3DS just in the last year. A proper follow up RPG should be on the shortlist for future Switch games. Of course, this is just wishful thinking given that there are no rumors, leaks, or cryptic messages from Nintendo that would indicate a true successor to one of its greatest games. | Michael Higham
